Allie Elder

Allie Elder

REALTOR® with the Expert Advisor Team Licensed in: WI, MN (608) 790-4982

About Allie

My approach to real estate is simple: be honest, be accessible, and make sure you always feel supported — not sold to. I don’t sugarcoat things just to “make a sale.” Instead, I give you straightforward advice, point out the positives and potential concerns, and outline your options so you always feel informed, confident, and in control.

Buying or selling a home can feel like a juggling act — and that’s exactly where I thrive. I bring clear communication, realistic expectations, and a proven strategy to keep the process manageable instead of overwhelming.

For first-time home buyers in the La Crosse area, I take the time to answer every question, explain each step in plain language, and make sure you always know what to expect. My goal is to replace nerves with knowledge and transform overwhelm into confidence.

As a Castle Realty agent, I’m proud to serve La Crosse, Onalaska, Holmen, West Salem, and the entire Coulee Region. I’m also licensed in Minnesota, helping clients in La Crescent and nearby river communities make smooth, informed moves. Whether you’re buying your first home, upgrading to your forever home, or relocating to the area, I’ll help you create a personalized strategy that fits your life, your goals, and your timeline.

When I’m not working with clients, I’m usually enjoying all the Coulee Region has to offer with my family or hanging out with my spoiled German Shepherd, Enzo.

 I believe in good coffee, honest conversations, and finding homes that truly fit the life you’re building.

The covered hotel stay when we listed was a lifesaver! Allie in general was absolutely incredible and made everything a breeze. Allie was amazing and made everything seamless. She walked with us every step of the way and patiently worked with us for over a year to buy and sell homes. She is incredible and knowledgeable in her role!

– Jessie K, La Crosse, WI

The Expert Advisor Team Includes:

  • Listing Agents
  • Buyers Agents
  • Showing Agents
  • Marketing Director
  • Transaction Coordinator
  • Operations Director
  • Moving Trailers for Client Use

All working together to take your transaction from the beginning to close with individual expertise and a common goal.

The Castle Realty of La Crosse Expert Advisor Team is proud to be one of the most trusted and respected real estate teams in the Coulee Region and surrounding areas. Castle Realty has been voted La Crosse County’s “Best Real Estate Company” from 2018–2025, a testament to the trust our community places in us. With over 200 5-star Google reviews, our clients continue to share the impact of our service, guidance, and care.

Our mission is to distinguish ourselves by providing business from the heart to our clients, our team, and our community. At Castle Realty, we create an environment where growth is continual, potential is discovered, and mediocrity is never accepted. We are dedicated to equipping our agents with the industry’s best tools, training, and support so every client receives an outstanding experience and maximum value on every transaction.

We are always looking for driven and dedicated professionals who want to grow, contribute, and succeed. Castle Realty offers comprehensive training, a collaborative team culture, and a supportive workplace designed to help agents reach their full potential. (Please Note: Castle Realty of La Crosse operates on a full time, fast paced schedule and is not for everyone.)

My Sold Listings

N15508 Harris Rd
Trempealeau, WI 54661
2 Beds
1F 1H Bath
$222,400
Courtesy of: RE/MAX Results
2906 23rd St S
La Crosse, WI 54601
2 Beds
1F 1H Bath
$220,000
Courtesy of: Castle Realty, LLC
2508 Island Park Rd
La Crosse, WI 54603
3 Beds
1F 1H Bath
$249,900
Courtesy of: Castle Realty, LLC
520 White Tail Dr
Stoddard, WI 54658
4 Beds
2F Bath
$349,900
Courtesy of: RE/MAX Results
W21889 Cox Rd
Galesville, WI 54630
4 Beds
2F 1H Bath
$385,000
Courtesy of: Assist 2 Sell Premium Choice Realty, LLC
1011 Evenson Dr
Sparta, WI 54656
4 Beds
2F Bath
$380,000
Courtesy of: La Crosse by Owner, LLC
1061 Hanson Pl S
Sparta, WI 54656
5 Beds
3F Bath
$439,900
Courtesy of: @properties La Crosse
1912 Main St E
Onalaska, WI 54650
3 Beds
2F Bath
$319,900
Courtesy of: Castle Realty, LLC
1500 Cliffview Ave
Onalaska, WI 54650
5 Beds
3F Bath
$500,000
Courtesy of: Edina Realty, Inc.
1060 Frontage Rd
Dakota, MN 55925
3 Beds
1F 1H Bath
$269,900
Courtesy of: Gerrard-Hoeschler, REALTORS
101 Oak St N
Rockland, WI 54653
3 Beds
2F Bath
$155,000
Courtesy of: @properties La Crosse
210 Kay St
Holmen, WI 54636
2 Beds
1F Bath
$180,000
Courtesy of: Castle Realty, LLC
S6004 Pedretti Ln
De Soto, WI 54624
3 Beds
3F 1H Bath
$390,000
Courtesy of: Castle Realty, LLC
W21301 Browns Addition Ln W21303
Galesville, WI 54630
Duplex
$262,600
Courtesy of: Castle Realty, LLC
2017 Charles St
La Crosse, WI 54603
2 Beds
1F Bath
$170,000
Courtesy of: Castle Realty, LLC
2103 State Rd
La Crosse, WI 54601
2 Beds
1F 1H Bath
$209,900
Courtesy of: Coldwell Banker River Valley, REALTORS
1213 Caroline St
La Crosse, WI 54603
2 Beds
1F Bath
$154,900
Courtesy of: Castle Realty, LLC
2717 Meadow Lark Ln S
Holmen, WI 54636
4 Beds
2F Bath
$329,000
Courtesy of: RE/MAX Results